When it comes to deciding between Old Town vs New Town Edinburgh, you’re really choosing between two sides of the same coin: one steeped in medieval charm, the other a showcase of Georgian elegance.
I’ve stayed in both, wandered every winding alley and wide boulevard, and I can say with full confidence: each has its own unique magic.
But depending on your priorities (sightseeing, atmosphere, nightlife, or peace and quiet), one area may be a better fit than the other.
Here’s what it’s really like to stay in each.
Old Town is the heart and soul of historic Edinburgh.
This is where you’ll find the Royal Mile, stretching from the Edinburgh Castle down to Holyrood Palace, and lined with everything from tartan shops and whisky tastings to centuries-old pubs.
It’s dark, mysterious, and undeniably romantic, especially when the mist rolls in.
Walking around the Old Town feels like stepping into a time machine.
Narrow closes, uneven cobblestone lanes, and gothic architecture surround you at every turn.
If this is your first time in Edinburgh, or you’ve come for the city’s history, this is where you want to be.
Accommodation here ranges from charming guesthouses tucked into ancient buildings to high-end hotels with views of the castle.
Most of the city’s top sights are right at your doorstep, which means you can explore without ever stepping on a bus or tram.
But with all that charm comes a few trade-offs.
The Old Town can be touristy and busy, especially during summer and the Fringe Festival. Some streets are noisy late at night, and walking around (especially with luggage) can be tiring thanks to all the hills and stairs.
If you’re after a quiet or modern stay, you might be better off just across the valley.
Cross over Princes Street Gardens, and you’ll find yourself in New Town, a world of symmetry, Georgian architecture, and wide streets.
Don’t let the name fool you, New Town is still over 200 years old, but compared to the medieval maze of the Old Town, it feels positively modern.
The vibe here is more refined and relaxed.
Think boutique shops, cozy cafés, cocktail bars, and wide boulevards like George Street that are perfect for strolling.
It’s where you’ll find Edinburgh’s shopping scene and a lot of its best restaurants, from high-end Scottish cuisine to international flavors.
New Town is also where many locals live, which gives it a more lived-in feel.
You’ll find a good mix of visitors and residents, and it’s generally quieter at night than the Old Town.
It’s also flatter and easier to navigate, which makes it a more comfortable base if you’re staying for several days.
There are plenty of hotels, stylish apartments, and some affordable guesthouses too.
And with Waverley Station right in between the Old and New Town, you’re still very central, nothing is too far.
Choose Old Town if you:
Choose New Town if you:
Honestly, you can’t go wrong, Edinburgh is compact and walkable, and it’s easy to explore both sides no matter where you stay.
But if you want the full medieval drama, go Old Town.
If you want a quieter and classier base, New Town is your spot.
Or do what I often recommend: split your stay and enjoy the best of both worlds.
